Skip to content
HHackerTube.videoSurprise me

The Future of War, and How It Affects YOU (Multi-Domain Operations) - Smarter Every Day 211

The Future of War, and How It Affects YOU (Multi-Domain Operations) - Smarter Every Day 211 on HackerTube: recommended by 4 Hacker News commenters across 4 separate months, 2019–2022.

Destin Sandlin of Smarter Every Day explains Multi-Domain Operations through footage from his last mission at RIMPAC 2018. He covers missile and torpedo testing and interviews military leaders about the cyber and information domains.

Why Hacker News recommends it

HN cites it for an insider's look at defense work and at how the military thinks about information operations and cyberspace.

people recommended it
4
separate months
4
strong recommendations
0
discussed on HN
2019–2022
“It's an insightful how-and-why explanation for those wondering why there aren't more conscientious objectors”
— drak0n1c, Apr 2019, in “Tech Needs More Conscientious Objectors”

What HN commenters said

17 Hacker News comments link this video. Each one links back to its thread.

incomingpainSep 2022Recommends

Check out this video by 'smertereveryday': ▶ this video He has access to a 4 star general who gives him a little too much information. The first screen in the video is that it has been approved for public release. The military understands the situation. You can see why they are purchasing internet data. I don't see the problem. Who exactly has been punished by this? Or even snowden? NSA is spying on everyone? But is there people in prison for this? If so, were they people who did need to go to prison? You can pretty much bet every country has 'lawful intercept'

in “Whistleblower: Pentagon purchased tool collecting Americans' web browsing data” · View on HN

101404Apr 2020Recommends

That's really just the result of the decreasing trust within society. "Bowling Alone" is a good book that tries to explore the underlying reasons for this development, that started some time in the 1960s. The current "war" in cyberspace probably contributes to it as well. Here is an interesting interview with a US four star general about that new area of conflict: ▶ this video

in “The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19” · View on HN

101404Apr 2020Recommends

Sadly, that is very likely a main reason. Political discussion isn't so much about the exchange of views anymore, but about "winning" and "destroying" the other side. And there is a reason for that. There is an interesting interview with a US 4-Star General about the topic of "controlling the public" in cyberspace: ▶ this video

in “The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19” · View on HN

godelskiAug 2019Recommends

Relevant video by Smarter Every Day[0]. Basically interviewing military people talk about the information part of war in the modern era. > I just made a weapon?! -Dustin @21:35 [0] ▶ this video

in “U.S. Unleashes Military to Fight Fake News, Disinformation” · View on HN

drak0n1cApr 2019Recommends

I see the point but it is a narrow and modernist characterization of other minds on the matter. A lot of perfectly decent people do defense work and don't really need the paychecks (the famous Youtuber SmarterEveryDay comes to mind). Here are a few reasons why: 1) Many work on oft maligned technologies because they simply see no moral conundrum. It's common to see tools as amoral, and believe moral responsibility in the use of tools for good or evil lies solely with its wielder - not any inventor or refiner. 2) Or, they may see their work as their moral duty as a competent professional in a society fending off morally worse alternatives. This is the patriotic or "necessary evil" view. 3) A few utilitarian engineers see the refinement of technology in and of itself as always a subtle moral good, as they believe the elimination of inefficiency is the primary reason why humanity no longer suffers as much as it used to. There's also the assumption that the development of any kind of tech leads to unanticipated benefits to other areas of life (this is a common demonstrated pattern in defense R&D). 4) There's also the classical Greek justification of Eudaimonia. Simply doing what one does best is seen as the most moral thing one can do, as it eliminates any outward and internal dishonesty about ones self. PS: Here is a great video by SmarterEveryDay explaining what he does and why ▶ this video

in “Tech Needs More Conscientious Objectors” · View on HN

drak0n1cApr 2019Recommends

The educational Youtube channel SmarterEveryDay made a video about his day job as a military rocket engineer. It's an insightful how-and-why explanation for those wondering why there aren't more conscientious objectors: ▶ this video

in “Tech Needs More Conscientious Objectors” · View on HN

Show 11 more comments
mtgaJan 2022Cites it

This might be it: ▶ this video From 2019: "For the last 15 years I have worked for the Army Test Evaluation Command."

in “James Webb telescope reaches its final destination in space, million miles away” · View on HN

godelskiDec 2020Cites it

Just the other day I brought up that many countries use things like memes to modify public perception. Topic was about China but I brought up that everyone else does it too (US, Russia, Israel, Germany, etc) and people thought it was insane and a conspiracy theory(specifically that anyone would want to influence Reddit because it is "a small website"). It honestly feels like we're gaslighting ourselves because this topic has been so openly discussed over the last 50 years that it is hard to say that this isn't happening. Though maybe because I suggested agencies use memes now instead of more well known sock puppets. Even on HN news I've been downvoted for this. I guess people don't think memes are being weaponized, even when they are explicitly referred to as such by those in the military[0] and other agencies. Actually one thing I've liked about The Boys (on Prime) is how it shows the viral marketing of Stormfront and how it is manipulating people (and how people didn't even notice the not even remotely subtle naming of the character). I guess that just shows how effective of a tool all this is. [0] ▶ this video

in “Ex‐FBI operative says he worked to disrupt political activities up to '74 (1975)” · View on HN

godelskiJul 2020Cites it

> If it was a foreign military's advanced aircraft, this is them admitting that, yep, your stealth/whatever technology works great, and we are baffled by it. I have an alternative explanation that also matches with history. They know what it is but don't want to tell the public. They can also feed bad information to adversaries like China and Russia who may interpret this is over confidence in their technologies. Here's a simple analogy. My cat is really dumb and will step right in front of me in the middle of the night when it is dark because she thinks I can see her (because she can see me). So at night I over exaggerate my inability to see in the dark. Now she thinks she is super sneaky (she's not) but also gets out of my way at night. All wars (especially cold wars, like the one we're in) are about information control. There is lots of propaganda, misdirection, lying, etc. An adversary having over confidence in their technology means that they will use it with that confidence. Think about WW2 and when the Enigma encryption was broken by Turing's team. They didn't reveal that they broke the encryption and let some people be attacked and prevented others (this led to some of the big foundations in game theory as well). Now we know this is a possibility, so do the Russians and Chinese. But the pentagon could also be telling the truth. These videos could also be complete fabrications or lucky shots that are natural phenomena that fool instruments. If Russia has the tech and d

in “Pentagon's UFO Unit to Disclose Some of Its Findings to the Public” · View on HN

vaidhyJul 2020Cites it

Destin, the person behind Smarter Every Day was ex-military and he interviewed his old commanding officer. It was clearly mentioned that the military is doing this to reach out to potential recruits while sharing interesting knowledge. I believe the actual episode is ▶ this video

in “Sailor pictured with laser rifle on board USS Minnesota nuclear sub” · View on HN

polytelyJul 2020Cites it

Ok so destin works as a scientist for the us gov. He did a video a while ago where he interviewed a general about the cyber domain of warfare. In this interview they discussed that the interview itself was part of that cyber domain, and the access they provide to destin is a part of the US presence in the cyber domain. [0] The pentagon clearly sees smarter everyday as a channel to spread information to a certain audience, to show off US capability and serve as a recruitment material. I respect Destin a lot and I think the video is very cool, but I feel that I should add a sort of disclaimer because I'm actively aiding the US gov by spreading this video? they obviously don't care about you knowing it's propaganda, but it cant hurt to emphasize it. Tbh my thinking about this isn't that crystallized yet but I thought it might spark an interesting side discussion. 0: ▶ this video see 21:00+ for cyberdomain talk

in “Sailor pictured with laser rifle on board USS Minnesota nuclear sub” · View on HN

kickMar 2020Cites it

ATEC handles basically everything under the sun. I'm not that familiar with him, but he mentions a couple of types he's helped test for ATEC in this video: ▶ this video [link] [link] Judging by the video's contents, he's worked on more than just missiles. I'm not trying to absolve Uber or something, for the record: the people who work for Uber aren't innocent, either. It just seems clear that they're a lesser evil. Malpractice versus malfeasance.

in “The core memory inside a Saturn V rocket's computer” · View on HN

comboyMar 2020Cites it

The whole idea behind these trolls is that they repeat stuff until it becomes popular opinion. It's hard to stay objective, we tend to agree with majority (Asch cconformity experiments would be an example but this is way more subtle and harder to control). You are correct with the war. And what we are talking about is not even a conspiracy theory. You can watch a top US general talking about it [1]. I see almost no comments like yours, only how China is evil. There is propaganda on both sides. But what worries me that here in the west most people don't seem to be aware of it. I think people accepted that political news they are getting is biased based on who is delivering it, but somehow it is not generalized to politics outside the country. 1. ▶ this video

in “Huawei is dividing Western nations” · View on HN

mistermannDec 2019Cites it

Considering some of the confidential things that have accidentally leaked into the public sphere in the last few years, I think it's fairly safe to assume at this point that US/Western government(s) and tech firms have a fairly collaborative relationship. Some people even suggest [0] this relationship extends into strategic, multi-domain operations, but since such ideas are obviously conspiracy theories (and therefore conclusively false, as per the epistemically infallible Occam's Razor technique), they should be considered only for their entertainment value. [link] ▶ this video

in “New disclosures to our archive of state-backed information operations” · View on HN

godelskiSep 2019Cites it

Reading the linked Vice article >"Based on pilot accounts, encounters with these UAPs (unidentified aerial phenomena) often involved complex flight patterns and advanced maneuvering, which demand extreme advances in quantum mechanics, nuclear science, electromagnetics, and thermodynamics.” - Walker > Republican representative Mark Walker of North Carolina This is laughably stupid. QM and nuclear science? Can we call out politicians for just throwing in words that they don't know what they mean? Seriously, I think we should call these people out. I'll even laugh at the extreme part. My bet is that these things are just some test drones. They might have advanced materials and so you can't trust a lot of the data coming into the FLIR sensor. I don't think it would surprise anyone here that the people making the "most advanced sensors on the market " 1) have more advanced sensors being researched/tested 2) don't perform adversarial attacks on those sensors during testing. As for the visuals, well drones can pull Gs that pilots can't. So if we can't trust the sensor readings (speed and size) and we just see something zipping around, it shouldn't surprise anyone that a drone _could_ be the culprit. As to the article, this is clearly misdirection. But that's part of warfare. ▶ this video

in “Tom Delonge’s UFO Research Center Is Making Politicians Demand Answers” · View on HN

legoheadMay 2019Cites it

You left out flat out lying in an attempt to sway the human domain towards a certain solution: say, military budgets. ▶ this video

in “UFOs invading military airspace multiple times a month, but public won't be told” · View on HN

comboyMar 2019Cites it

Thanks for a detailed explanation. That seems pretty radical. I mean, because of technology progress (mainly crypto improvements, but also cheaper hardware development) I only see two outcomes in the future: (it's a global issue, not just related to Russia) 1. We have a complete freedom of information exchange. It's a powerful thing. It's not only free speech, but also easily available all illegal digital content and ability to transfer money anonymously. In such scenario, it's inevitable that governments role will diminish. Well, they are huge and powerful, they can still retain a huge influence (and already do * ) by manipulating people, the software they use etc. 2. The Internet as we know it today ceases to exist. Basically what you wrote above and much more. Pretty dark scenario. I always hoped that enough big players (who are able to influence gov) depend enough on the way the Internet currently works, that it would be very hard push this. Maybe not as hard as I thought. Because note that most people, majority of users, simply don't care. Leave top 100 websites working (power law traffic distribution) and most people won't notice the difference. *. ▶ this video

in “Thousands of Russians protest against internet restrictions” · View on HN

Topics & tags

Military history & warfareEveryday physics & science demosmulti-domain operationscyber warfaremilitaryinformation operationssmarter every day