Skip to content
HHackerTube.videoSurprise me

Surreal Numbers (writing the first book) - Numberphile

Surreal Numbers (writing the first book) - Numberphile on HackerTube: recommended by 3 Hacker News commenters across 2 separate months, 2016–2022.

Numberphile

interview · evergreen

Open on YouTube

A Numberphile interview with Donald Knuth about how he came to write the first book on surreal numbers after a lunch with John Conway. He tells the story casually in about 14 minutes.

Why Hacker News recommends it

Recommended as a short, charming introduction to surreal numbers and to how Knuth wrote his book in under a week.

people recommended it
3
separate months
2
strong recommendations
1
discussed on HN
2016–2022
“This interview is excellent”
— knuthsat, Jun 2021, in “Surreal Numbers – An Introduction (2019) [pdf]”

What HN commenters said

4 Hacker News comments link this video. Each one links back to its thread.

knuthsatJun 2021Strongly recommends

Knuth has a nice book on Surreal numbers. [link] This interview is excellent ▶ this video He wrote the book in less than a week, the book was just flowing for days and after that he couldn't write a thing. Then he realized he missed a detail and had to rewrite the whole book.

in “Surreal Numbers – An Introduction (2019) [pdf]” · View on HN

AndrewOMartinDec 2022Recommends

You sounds like you'd enjoy learning about the Surreal Numbers. ▶ this video (15m video starring Don Knuth) [link] (1h15m video starring John Conway) It may be the case that you've already heard of the Surreal Numbers, but I remain confident you enjoyed learning about them. :)

in “The Pirahã Are Off by One (2020)” · View on HN

maxbondJun 2021Recommends

You can safely ignore it, the document is just a summary of Knuth's book. And it's a good one, I found it very helpful when I was working through the book. I found I had to read the material from several different sources to understand, in addition to working things out on paper/in code. I'm not religious myself but honestly that seems like a perfectly reasonable motivation. While there are some people who believe the Surreals could lead to a deeper form of analysis, I think the most common reason to learn them is to apprehend something beautiful without any sort of utility. But as a heads up, if that doesn't sit right with you, then Knuth's book is probably not right for you either; it's framed in the style of the old testament. On the first day, Conway created zero, and saw that it was good; things like that. This may be more to your taste. ▶ this video [link] [link]

in “Surreal Numbers – An Introduction (2019) [pdf]” · View on HN

decentralityJun 2016Cites it

I love how a famous forefather ( turned 3:16 experimenter and muser on metaphysics, etc ) suddenly throws in how he wanted to role play cheating in a hotel during the course of research in Oslo, and that was his wife's expectation if he was going to squeeze composing another book into their marriage. It was so nonchalant it was just thrown in as if he was describing the napkin with the theory on it: ▶ this video "Because we liked to have an affair in the hotel room." "So that was the plan."

in “Donald Knuth: Surreal Numbers [video]” · View on HN

Topics & tags

Recreational & visual mathTech pioneers & interviewsdonald knuthjohn conwaysurreal numbersnumberphilemathematics history