Skip to content
HHackerTube.videoSurprise me

The Lively & Liveable Neighbourhoods that are Illegal in Most of North America

The Lively & Liveable Neighbourhoods that are Illegal in Most of North America on HackerTube: recommended by 5 Hacker News commenters across 5 separate months, 2021–2024.

Not Just Bikes

explainer · evergreen

Open on YouTube

Not Just Bikes explains how small pockets of shops and restaurants inside residential Dutch neighbourhoods create liveliness and help reduce traffic. It argues this kind of mixed-use design has been illegal in most of the US and Canada for a century because of zoning, and should be brought back.

Why Hacker News recommends it

HN commenters link it in zoning, housing and car-dependency threads as an accessible explanation of how single-use zoning and parking rules shape cities.

people recommended it
5
separate months
5
strong recommendations
0
discussed on HN
2021–2024
“Not Just Bikes talks about zoning in the US vs Dutch cities in this video”
— ruuda, Aug 2021, in “Reading Hayek in Holland”

What HN commenters said

14 Hacker News comments link this video. Each one links back to its thread.

xputerJul 2022Recommends

Oh boy you are in for a treat. Google parking minimums and single family zoning. And watch some videos from this channel: ▶ this video

in “Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes” · View on HN

est31May 2022Recommends

No but there is way less dependence on cars, at least in medium cities and up. Many developments in america just build suburban deserts where there is just more single family homes around you, where you have to drive to the next supermarket, both because it's so far away, and because sometimes there literally isn't a way for pedestrians to walk on. There are a few good videos on the subject: * [link] * ▶ this video * [link]

in “An autonomous car in SF blocked a fire truck responding to an emergency” · View on HN

stormgrabOct 2021Recommends

The whole medieval cities designed for walking is not actually true. Not just bikes youtube channel( ▶ this video ) has a great video about this. Here he has taken Houston as an example.

in “Amazon will allow many employees to work remotely indefinitely” · View on HN

benrbrayAug 2021Recommends

There is something in between NYC and an American-style suburb. I encourage you to take a look at Not Just Bikes [1,2]: [1] [link] [2] ▶ this video

in “Why are so many knowledge workers quitting?” · View on HN

rossngApr 2021Recommends

Yes, and it's often referred to as 'gentle density'. The idea is to build relatively dense housing, but at a human scale - mostly 3-5 storeys. Combined with narrow streets that support walking and cycling, this creates enough density to support a 'real' city centre with shops, restaurants, offices and so on. I think these videos convey the idea well: * ▶ this video * [link] Of course, this is not to say that you _can't_ build other kinds of housing. But many cities are badly balanced.

in “A billion for every chip-maker who 'makes in India,' sources say” · View on HN

k99x55May 2024Cites it

The Lively & Liveable Neighbourhoods that are Illegal in Most of North America : ▶ this video The Suburbs Are Bleeding America Dry | Climate Town (feat. Not Just Bikes) : [link]

in “Measuring the impact of zoning on housing in a city” · View on HN

Show 8 more comments
kd913Mar 2024Cites it

Just gonna also say the current US zoning laws are batty when it comes to sustainability. You shouldn’t segment commercial and residential zones and suburbia in general is a massive disaster. You want sustainable cities, you need high dense walkable cities with commercial spaces embedded. Sure move the giant factories somewhere else, but we shouldn’t oppose small scale sustainable businesses being embedded in residential zones. ▶ this video

in “The Fed's Big Problem, There Are Two Economies but Only One Interest Rate” · View on HN

CalRobertAug 2023Cites it

Annnnnd why is it that cities aren't building denser housing? (it's because it's illegal. Because of parking minimums, density maximums, and level of service rules. Which exist because of cars. Which you need to go 10 miles because everything is so far apart. Because of those rules. Because of cars.) ▶ this video

in “Luckily I got hit by a car” · View on HN

greggman3Jan 2023Cites it

AirBnB sux but zoning has arguably been a net negative on most societies in many ways ▶ this video [link] for me what I noticed lately is that in California it's impossible to have a quiet modern apartment because nearly 100% of modern apartment buildings are only allowed to be built on busy noisy high traffic streets. If you want a quiet street you're forced to buy/rent a house

in “Airbnb removed my negative review” · View on HN

gernbSep 2022Cites it

Many of those codes have been designed to protect incombents from competition and various other forms of encouraging one form of living (car dependent) over others. Plenty of people in Japan, Korea, Hong Kong, etc live happy lives in much much smaller living areas. This makes them more affordable. But building codes in many places in the USA disallow making places that small. Other examples of questionable codes are codes that require parking spaces, codes that require front yards, codes that require backyards, etc.... [link] ▶ this video

in “San Francisco braces for commercial real estate crash” · View on HN

rglullisJul 2022Cites it

> regulations or policies that push development away from suburbs and into cities. I misspoke. By "getting rid of suburbia", I mean getting rid of American-style, car-centric suburban development. You'll absolutely want to have development in the suburbs. And to do that, you don't need a lot of changes in regulations. Surely, you'll have to fight with NIMBYs, but these changes do not require massive regulations: - Upzoning all R1 zones, and abolish Euclidian Zone. Just by getting rid of exclusive single-family zones that are so prevalent in the US, and start allowing multi-family townhouses, mixed-use areas, you could recover basically every city that is not part of coastal metro area: ▶ this video - Transit-oriented development. City Beautiful has a great video about it: [link]

in “Manhattan rents cross $5k threshold for first time” · View on HN

drivers99Apr 2022Cites it

To back up what you said: The Lively & Liveable Neighbourhoods that are Illegal in Most of North America (Not Just Bikes channel) ▶ this video

in “Vancouver Zoning Map” · View on HN

ruudaAug 2021Cites it

Not Just Bikes talks about zoning in the US vs Dutch cities in this video: ▶ this video . My impression was that the US has more restrictive regulations on what can be built.

in “Reading Hayek in Holland” · View on HN

screyeFeb 2021Cites it

Urban Design and police has become a kafkaesque mess. It has become near impossible to summon the political will to actually build something livable. Developments generally lean towards familiar and easy, instead of building anything interesting. Tragically, in many parts of the world, one of 3 types of plans fall in the easy+familiar domain. You have the grossly inefficient suburbs of the US, lifeless concrete planned cities of communist fame and wild-best of haphazard urban densification as seen in Indian cities like Bangalore. What's even worse, is that the average consumer is woefully under-equipped to recognize problems with this system until it is too late. It isn't until their kids start growing up that they realize how dead the suburb feels, and how the car dependence relegates one of the parents to a soccer mom nanny. Why it takes 2 hours to get to anywhere in Bangalore or why the incredibly dense concrete jungle feels spiritually dead despite how hard you try to fix it. Years of brainwashing towards the American dream and a tall condo with a view, really do not help consumers make informed decisions either. Not like contractors do user-studies anyways, but still. Funny thing is, these problems are already solved in some capacity. City has been studied to death for millennia. It is no wonder that people in modern 1st world countries, pay good money to spend 1 week in European cities that have been "preserved" as they were. I am not even advocating for some replica of

in “Why Tech Moguls Are Obsessed with Building Utopian Cities” · View on HN

Topics & tags

Transit, cities & urban planningSocial issues & culturezoningurban planningnetherlandscar dependencywalkable neighbourhoods