Why do YouTube views freeze at 301? on HackerTube: recommended by 1 Hacker News commenter across 1 month, 2012–2025.
explainer · dated
Numberphile visits YouTube to learn why view counts on new videos used to freeze at 301. It explains that YouTube holds counts while it verifies views aren't from bots or fakes.
Linked whenever the 301 view freeze or view-count validation comes up, as the standard short explanation.
“here's a good video on why it happens”
6 Hacker News comments link this video. Each one links back to its thread.
They cache view counts heavily on highly viewed videos for validating views, here's a good video on why it happens (with information from Youtube -- the 301 refers to the first point at which video views stop incrementing in real time): ▶ this video
in “Gangnam Style hitting 1 billion YouTube views” · View on HN
From the GitHub issue it becomes clear that blocking happens by the EasyPrivacy blocklist. The blocked URL youtube.com/api/stats/atr is/can also be used for tracking users, this is why some are arguing that it legitimately on that blocklist. The tracking not malicious. YouTube has a legitimate interest to verify views, e.g. to recommend popular videos to others. If a view counter was increased by just invoking an API, view counts could be manipulated easily. Also see the video [1] from ... 13 years ago ... so it might be slighly outdated. Just slightly. [1] ▶ this video
in “YouTube addresses lower view counts which seem to be caused by ad blockers” · View on HN
You probably think of Numberphile explanation of why YouTube videos (used to) stay at 301 views for a while - leading to lots of confusion when the site showed 301 views with 5728 comments and 37592 likes. ▶ this video
in “YouTube Oddities” · View on HN
It may be related to the famous 301 view count where YouTube would stop updating the total pending further verification that the views are legitimate. See: ▶ this video This behavior was later removed in 2015, but I wouldn’t be surprised if something similar is happening here.
in “Ask HN: Why do so many YouTube videos have exactly 54 upvotes?” · View on HN
There's a good reason for it, and usually is a sign that the video is immensely popular. You can find out why on Youtube it self: ▶ this video
in “Elon Musk’s SpaceX Is Testing Technology To Make Rockets Reusable” · View on HN
Or, someone at youtube saw the video and thought it was cool. Like how this video will always have 301 views: ▶ this video
in “This Video Has X Views” · View on HN